Author(s): G.Sivaraj
Paper Details: Volume 3, Issue 4
Citation: IJLSSS 3(4) 37
Page No: 469 – 492
ABSTRACT
The rapid growth of e-commerce has revolutionized the way people shop, providing convenience and access to a wide range of products. However, this digital transformation has also given rise to unique legal challenges regarding product liability and consumer protection. This abstract provides an overview of the key legal issues associated with product liability and consumer protection in the age of e-commerce.Product liability in e-commerce involves holding online sellers, platforms, and manufacturers accountable for defective or dangerous products. Traditional product liability laws designed for physical retail environments must be adapted to address the complexities of the online marketplace. Challenges arise due to the lack of physical interaction between the consumer and the product, as well as the involvement of multiple parties in the supply chain. Determining liability and jurisdiction becomes more complex when products are sold across borders, requiring an examination of international legal frameworks and harmonization efforts.Consumer protection in e-commerce focuses on safeguarding the rights and interests of online shoppers. Online transactions often lack the transparency and personal interaction of traditional retail settings, which increases the risk of fraudulent practices, misleading advertising, and unfair terms and conditions. Effective consumer protection measures need to address issues such as clear and accurate product information, secure payment mechanisms, protection against counterfeit products, and responsive customer support.
KEYWORDS
Liability and jurisdiction, Online transactions, e-commerce focuses on safeguarding, adapting existing laws , emphasizing transparency.
INTRODUCTION
In the age of e-commerce, the landscape of product liability and consumer protection has evolved significantly. With the rapid growth of online shopping platforms and digital marketplaces, consumers now have access to a vast array of products from all around the world at their fingertips. While e-commerce offers convenience and accessibility, it also presents unique legal challenges in ensuring product safety and safeguarding consumer rights.Product liability refers to the legal responsibility of manufacturers, distributors, and sellers for any harm or injuries caused by their products. In traditional brick-and-mortar retail, the supply chain is relatively straightforward, making it easier to trace and identify responsible parties. However, the decentralized nature of e-commerce introduces complexities, as products can be sourced from various sellers, often located in different jurisdictions. Consumer protection laws aim to safeguard the interests and rights of consumers, ensuring fair trade practices, product safety, and accurate information disclosure. These laws address issues such as false advertising, deceptive practices, fraud, and the right to refunds or returns. In the digital realm, consumer protection becomes more challenging due to the global nature of e-commerce and the anonymity it can afford to sellers.This article will explore the legal issues surrounding product liability and consumer protection in the age of e-commerce. We will examine the challenges faced by consumers and businesses alike, as well as the efforts made by lawmakers and regulatory bodies to adapt to the changing landscape. Additionally, we will discuss the role of emerging technologies, such as blockchain and artificial intelligence, in enhancing product safety and consumer protection in the e-commerce environment. By understanding the legal complexities and emerging trends in e-commerce, we can shed light on the measures necessary to ensure a safe and fair marketplace for consumers and foster trust in online transactions.The combination of product liability and consumer protection in the age of e-commerce presents unique challenges for legal systems worldwide. This is primarily due to the borderless nature of online transactions, where products can be purchased from vendors located in different countries, making it difficult to establish jurisdiction and enforce legal remedies. Additionally, the rapid pace of technological advancements in e-commerce creates a constant need for legal frameworks to adapt and keep pace with emerging challenges.
OBJECTIVES
- To analyze the E-commerce companies have legal responsibility for ensuring the safety of the products they sell online .
- To examine the legal framework and regulations governing product liability and consumer protection in the age of e-commerce.
- To explore the challenges and implications of product liability and consumer protection in the e-commerce environment.
- To identify and analyze the legal issues related to product liability in the context of e-commerce.
LITERATURE REVIEW
This study focuses on the entry of luxury brands in the Chennai retail space and the strategies that luxury brands are employing to target customers who want to purchase luxury brands because of their brand image, exclusivity and excellent quality. The paper discusses how luxury brands with high quality, uniqueness and social value will appeal to people of different age groups, occupations, income groups and gender. Structural Equation Modeling has been employed to help marketers to understand how consumers perceive luxury brands and what features are considered most important by them. (“An Empirical Exploration of Consumer Buying Behaviour in the Age of Luxury Branding – with Special Reference to the Chennai Retail Market,” 2019) The aim of this thesis is to investigate the impact of branding on the behavior of Greek consumers towards olive oil products. The survey involved 488 consumers in Thessaloniki city. According to the research results, based on correlation test and t-test, it has been established that the preference for an olive oil brand is associated with increased brand awareness and higher levels of loyalty. Finally, it was found that higher consumption of olive oil is associated with a higher degree of brand recognition and stronger perceptions of its superiority to competitors.(Baziana & Tzimitra-Kalogianni, 2019) The main objective of this scientific paper is to define the complete Demand Management process along the supply chain. It is to be shown with which concepts the consumer goods industry can overcome the challenges. (Demand Management in the FMCG Sector. Concepts, Success Criteria and Trends, 2021) FMCG companies today face immense distribution related challenges owing to the complex supply chain structures and intense competition. Surviving is impossible without continuous distribution channel innovation. Companies with exceptional quality distribution systems are able to outperform their competitors, being able to provide higher customer satisfaction, while the rest perish.(Haddad, 2017)This book will provide detailed insight into the thinking of today’s consumers towards FMCG products. The book will highlight the paradigm shift in consumer mindset that has created challenges and opportunities for 21st century companies. Fundamental issues, risks, and challenges will be looked into to provide answers to the three magical questions.(Haddad, 2016) The book′s theories go beyond simply introducing the reader to concepts in the field by providing tools and methods to develop marketing thinking and questioning skills that will help with application of real-life marketing strategies. As the chapters progress, the thinking/questioning develops toward higher levels and more specialized inquiry, helping readers acquire the skills needed in the practice of marketing. (Hill, 2012) Availability of key raw materials, cheaper labor costs and presence across the entire value chain gives India a competitive advantage. The FMCG market is set to treble from US$ 11.6 billion in 2003 to US$ 33.4 billion in 2015. Penetration level as well as per capita consumption in most product categories like jams, toothpaste, skin care, hair wash etc in India is low indicating the untapped market Potential.(Jadhav, 2012)The minor points which usually people neglect can become a major threat in sales and distribution to cover up all the minutes of channel distribution. This book can stand as a helping hand to understand the system of sales and distribution for further growth and progress.(Khatib, 2020)This book analyzes the essential techniques and platforms of digital marketing including social media, content marketing, SEO, user experience, personalization, display advertising and CRM, as well as the broader aspects of implementation including planning, integration with overall company aims and presenting to decision makers.(Kingsnorth, 2016) To compete for the modern consumer it is critical to move from being an old-fashioned FMCG to being an FICG – a fast-innovating consumer goods company – but there are major internal and external hurdles to this transformation. Outdated communication strategies based on television, radio and print with constant repetition must be replaced by what the authors call ‘Lego’ strategies, whereby the marketing and communication strategies are built up by many key facets and delivered to the consumer through a mix of various touch points.(Lorange & Rembiszewski, 2014)In this study, by conducting a literature review and interviewing experts active in FMCG industries as an available case study, the most important challenges facing the AIoT-powered supply chain were extracted. By examining these challenges using nonlinear quantitative analysis, the importance of these challenges was examined and their causal relationships were identified. The results showed that cybersecurity and a lack of proper infrastructure are the most important challenges facing the AIoT-based supply chain.It has a strong MNC presence and is characterized by a well-established distribution network, intense competition between the organized and unorganized segments and low operational cost.(Nozari et al., 2022). This chapter analyzes the impact of digitalization on TV marketing strategies focusing on the role of brand as a loyalty-based resource, available to digital television networks to create a sustainable competitive advantage. The goal of this analysis is to offer insights on how a digital television network may create a channel experience leveraging on brand to increase viewers’ loyalty and competitive advantage.(Pagani, 2012) This book investigates this effect, one of the most controversial fields of consumer literature, from a company perspective. In particular, it demonstrates the strategic relevance of the country of origin in creating and making use of the value in foreign markets.(Pagan et al., 2019). To inform the development of regulatory strategies, it is important to understand how alcohol branding interacts with seductive pricing strategies to influence purchasing decisions. Toward this aim, the current study examines how the “decoy effect” may operate to modify purchasing decisions for branded alcoholic beverages.(Pennington et al., 2022)The strategies are formulated for the short and long run according to the goals of the company. The goals indicate what a company wants to achieve in a given environment and time frame; the strategy answers how to get there. Every business must develop a tailor-made strategy for achieving its goals. The corporate business strategies should possess three generic points: overall cost leadership, differentiation, and focus. (Rajagopal & Rajagopal, 2019) The study’s goal is to look at Covid-19’s pandemic and consumer survival as a mediator for the future of running a business when FMCG companies are doing well. The researchers employed a basic random sampling strategy to do a layered transverse evaluation of samples. EFA, CFA, and SEM are used to choose data collection techniques for participants at Covid-19.(Sun et al., 2021)This book is a history of some of the world’s most famous brands, from humble beginnings to current exalted status, from smudged, kitchen-table pamphlets to $ multi-million ad campaigns, from backyard experiments to global research. It examines the most recent developments in these glittering trajectories and reveals the very DNA of the brands themselves.(Thain & Bradley, 2014) The book′s theories go beyond simply introducing the reader to concepts in the field by providing tools and methods to develop marketing thinking and questioning skills that will help with application of real-life marketing strategies. As the chapters progress, the thinking/questioning develops toward higher levels and more specialized inquiry, helping readers acquire the skills needed in the practice of marketing.(Tiffany, 2021).
METHODOLOGY
The research method used here is an empirical method . Convenient sampling method is used to Collect the sample.A total of 200 samples have been collected online . The sample frame is taken from the general public in Chennai. The independent variable includes gender,age,occupations,educational qualifications.The dependent variables are A customer receiving a damaged product due to shipping mishandling, A customer being disappointed with the color of a product they ordered online, A customer receiving a defective product that causes injury or harm. The tools used are cluster bars .
ANALYSIS
FIGURE 1
LEGEND: Figure 1 shows does an E-commerce have legal responsibility for ensuring the safety of the products they sell online and the gender of the respondents.
FIGURE 2
LEGEND: Fig 2 represents the following examples of products liability in the age of E-commerce and the age of the respondents.
FIGURE 3
LEGEND: Fig 3 represents the agreeability towards factors affecting consumer protection [regulatory framework] and educational qualifications of the respondents.
FIGURE 4
LEGEND: Fig 4 represents the agreeability towards factors affecting consumer protection. [ Globalization ] and educational qualifications of the respondents.
FIGURE 5
LEGEND: Fig 5 represents the agreeability towards factors affecting consumer protection. [ Market competition] with the reference of educational qualifications.
FIGURE 6
LEGEND: Fig 6 represents the agreeability towards factors affecting consumer protection. [ information transparency] with the reference of educational qualifications.
FIGURE 7
LEGEND: Fig 7 represents the agreeability towards the factors affecting consumer protection. [ Technological advancement ] with the reference of educational qualifications.
FIGURE 8
LEGEND: Fig 8 represents the agreeability towards effects of products liability [safety] with the reference of gender.
FIGURE 9
LEGEND: Fig 9 represents the agreeability towards effects of product liability [litigation cost] by gender.
FIGURE 10
LEGEND: Fig 10 represents the agreeability towards effects of product liability [product design] by gender.
FIGURE 11
LEGEND: Fig 11 represents the agreeability towards effects of product liability [insurance premium] by gender.
FIGURE 12
LEGEND: Fig 12 represents the agreeability towards effects of product liability [innovation] by gender.
FIGURE 13
LEGEND: Fig 13 represents the agreeability towards effects of product liability [consumer trust] by gender.
RESULT: (Figure 1) Most of the respondents being male (44.98%) stated yes. (Figure 2) Most of the respondents from the age of 31-40 (22.97%) stated that a customer was disappointed with the color of a product they ordered online. (Figure 3) Most of the respondents from the UG strongly disagreed (26.79%) with the regulatory framework. (Figure 4) Most of the respondents from the high school (22.97%) strongly agree with globalization. (Figure 5) The majority of the respondents from UG remain neutral (22.97%) with market competition. (Figure 6 ) The majority of the respondents from the high school qualification remain neutral (22.97%). (Figure 7) Most of the respondents from high school remain neutral (22.97%) for technological advancements. (Figure 8) Most of the respondents being male strongly agree (22.97%) with safety. (Figure 9) Most of the respondents being male strongly disagreed (26.79%) with litigation cost. (Figure 10) The majority of the respondents being male (35.89%) strongly agree with product design. (Figure 11) Most of the respondents being male (35.89%) strongly agree with insurance premium. (Figure 12) Most of the respondents being male (22.97%) agree with innovation. (Figure 13) The majority of the respondents being male (26.79%) strongly agree with consumer trust.
DISCUSSION: Figure 1: The figure indicates that nearly half of the respondents were male (44.98%) and stated “yes.” It suggests that a significant portion of male respondents agrees with or supports a specific aspect, which needs to be specified further for a complete understanding of the context. Figure 2: The figure reveals that the largest group of respondents (22.97%) in the age range of 31-40 reported that a customer was disappointed with the color of a product ordered online. This finding highlights the relevance of product appearance and customer expectations in e-commerce transactions, indicating a potential concern related to product liability and consumer satisfaction. Figure 3: Among the respondents with an undergraduate (UG) qualification, the majority (26.79%) strongly disagreed with the regulatory framework. This indicates that a significant portion of UG respondents hold a negative perception of the existing regulations concerning product liability and consumer protection in e-commerce. Further investigation is necessary to understand the specific concerns and potential recommendations for improvement. Figure 4: In contrast to Figure 3, the figure shows that the majority of high school respondents (22.97%) strongly agree with globalization. This suggests a positive perception among high school respondents regarding the impact of globalization on product liability and consumer protection in the e-commerce context. The reasons behind this agreement require further exploration. Figure 5: The figure indicates that the majority of UG respondents (22.97%) remained neutral regarding market competition. This suggests a lack of strong opinions or a need for more information among UG respondents regarding the influence of market competition on product liability and consumer protection in e-commerce. Figure 6: Similar to Figure 5, the majority of high school respondents (22.97%) remained neutral. This indicates a similar trend of neutrality among high school respondents regarding the impact of market competition on product liability and consumer protection. Figure 7: The figure shows that the majority of high school respondents (22.97%) also remained neutral regarding technological advancements. This suggests that high school respondents may require more information or have mixed opinions regarding the influence of technological advancements on product liability and consumer protection. Figure 8: Among male respondents, the majority (22.97%) strongly agrees with safety. This indicates a positive perception among male respondents regarding the importance of safety measures in product liability and consumer protection. Figure 9: The figure indicates that most male respondents (26.79%) strongly disagreed with litigation cost. This suggests that male respondents perceive litigation costs as burdensome or unfavorable in the context of product liability and consumer protection. Figure 10: The majority of male respondents (35.89%) strongly agrees with product design. This highlights the importance of product design in the eyes of male respondents concerning product liability and consumer protection. Figure 11: Similarly, most male respondents (35.89%) strongly agree with insurance premium. This suggests that male respondents recognize the significance of insurance coverage in addressing product liability concerns. Figure 12: Among male respondents, the majority (22.97%) agrees with innovation. This indicates a positive perception among male respondents regarding the role of innovation in improving product liability and consumer protection in e-commerce. Figure 13: Lastly, the majority of male respondents (26.79%) strongly agree with consumer trust. This underscores the importance of establishing and maintaining consumer trust in the e-commerce landscape from the perspective of male respondents.
LIMITATIONS
One of the major limitations of the study in the sample frame. There is a major constraint in the sample frame as it is limited to a small area. Thus, it proves to be difficult to extrapolate it to a larger population. Another limitation is the sample size of 200 which cannot be used to assume the thinking of the entire population in the particular country, state or city. The physical factors have a larger impact, thus limiting the study.
CONCLUSION
The study on the examination of legal issues surrounding product liability and consumer protection in the age of e-commerce sheds light on several important aspects. Through the analysis of various figures, several key findings emerge. Firstly, it is evident that male respondents constituted a significant portion of the survey participants. Their responses highlight their perspectives on different aspects related to product liability and consumer protection. Secondly, the study reveals that customers’ dissatisfaction with product color was a common issue reported by respondents, particularly those in the age range of 31-40. This emphasizes the significance of product appearance and meeting customer expectations in e-commerce transactions, indicating a potential area for improvement in terms of consumer satisfaction and product liability. The survey also brings attention to the contrasting opinions regarding the regulatory framework. While a significant portion of respondents with an undergraduate qualification strongly disagreed with the regulatory framework, high school respondents expressed a strong agreement with globalization. This disparity suggests the need for a deeper examination of specific concerns and potential reforms regarding the existing regulations in the context of e-commerce. The figures also indicate a general trend of neutrality among respondents, both in terms of market competition and technological advancements. This suggests a requirement for further information and education on these topics to shape informed opinions and enhance understanding of their impact on product liability and consumer protection. Regarding gender-specific responses, male respondents exhibited positive attitudes towards safety, product design, insurance premium, innovation, and consumer trust. Conversely, they expressed strong disagreement with litigation costs. These findings emphasize the significance of safety measures, product design, insurance coverage, innovation, and consumer trust from the male respondents’ perspective in the realm of product liability and consumer protection. Overall, the study provides valuable insights into the legal issues surrounding product liability and consumer protection in the age of e-commerce. It identifies key areas of concern, highlights disparities in opinions, and suggests potential areas for improvement. The findings can guide policymakers, legal professionals, and businesses in enhancing consumer protection measures, addressing product liability concerns, and fostering a more transparent and trustworthy e-commerce environment.
REFERENCES
Tiffany, J. (2021). Marketing Strategy: Overcome Common Pitfalls and Create Effective Marketing. Kogan Page Publishers.
An empirical exploration of consumer buying behavior in the age of luxury branding – with special reference to the Chennai retail market. (2019). International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering, 8(3S2), 44–51.
Baziana, S., & Tzimitra-Kalogianni, E. (2019). Branding influence on consumer behavior regarding olive oil. Outlook on Agriculture, 48(2), 152–156.
Demand Management in the FMCG sector. Concepts, success criteria and trends. (2021). GRIN Verlag.
Haddad, M. (2016). 21st Century FMCG Consumer Marketing: Creating Customer Value by Putting Consumers at the Heart of FMCG Marketing Strategy. Lulu.com.
Haddad, M. (2017). FMCG Distribution Challenges & Workable Solutions. Lulu.com.
Hill, M. E. (2012). Marketing Strategy: The Thinking Involved. SAGE Publications.
Jadhav, G. (2012). Marketing and Distribution Strategy for Fmcg. LAP Lambert Academic Publishing.
Khatib, M. (2020). The Secret Jewels of FMCG Retail distribution & Channel sales. BecomeShakespeare.com.
Kingsnorth, S. (2016). Digital Marketing Strategy: An Integrated Approach to Online Marketing. Kogan Page Publishers.
Lorange, M. P., & Rembiszewski, M. J. (2014). From Great to Gone: Why FMCG Companies are Losing the Race for Customers. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd.
Nozari, H., Szmelter-Jarosz, A., & Ghahremani-Nahr, J. (2022). Analysis of the Challenges of Artificial Intelligence of Things (AIoT) for the Smart Supply Chain (Case Study: FMCG Industries). Sensors , 22(8). https://doi.org/10.3390/s22082931
Pagani, M. (2012). Branding Strategies for Digital TV Channels. In Branding and Sustainable Competitive Advantage (pp. 57–68). https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-61350-171-9.ch005
Pegan, G., Vianelli, D., & de Luca, P. (2019). International Marketing Strategy: The Country of Origin Effect on Decision-Making in Practice. Springer Nature.
Pennington, C. R., Monk, R. L., Qureshi, A. W., Kulkarni, R., Li, W., Li, J., & Heim, D. (2022). Dark Nudges: Branding Magnifies the Decoy Effect in Alcohol Purchasing Decisions. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 83(6), 857–866.
Rajagopal. (2019). Competitive Branding Strategies: Managing Performance in Emerging Markets. Springer Nature.
Rajagopal, & Rajagopal. (2019). Branding Strategy. In Competitive Branding Strategies (pp. 107–141). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-24933-5_4
Sun, Y., Li, Y., Wang, Y., Jiang, D., & Liu, X. (2021). A Future Forecasting for FMCG Firm Performance in Covid-19: An Investigation of Consumer and Business Survival. Frontiers in Public Health, 9, 723084.